they took the picture just a red puddle, as if it was Vladimir in his skill (game character), and no one took offense at it
That was because the system itself was designed (and described) as "If you really need just a few points you can give us drawings of the game, even if you're not good at drawing anything, and we'll decide if we can give them out".
This here was A CONTEST, in which only a few chosen (which supposedly are good at drawing) get the prize. That's the difference, and that is why you see "hate" here and not there. There everyone can do it once whenever they need or feel like it, here it had a time limit and it was more than just a few in-game points who would add up to nothing if were to be paid in real money.
Also, you say that you will give mug and outfit to other people, but if i understood correctly that would be against the rules. Paragraph 2 number 6. I personally wouldn't care, i don't even know which one yours is, but they do it seems (but do they?)
Now talking to all.
Re-reading the thread, there is nowhere when they say "the best ones will be selected", they just say "Gameforge will select a total of 20 works from amongst all eligible entries based on their respective creativity and originality", so it may be that they selected that drawing due to its irony or something like that. This means that even if you all are upset that one of the winners was a "troll" or "baby-like" or whatever, Gameforge didn't do anything wrong, they weren't incoherent. It may not have been beautiful, but it certainly had someone behind it who had this "idea", and since these drawings are what they are, you can't really be sure saying "it's uncreative and unoriginal".
And for those saying, or at least thinking, that they chose it because it was the only one from Rucco, there are quite a few server missing on the list, first of all my Uriel in which i know someone ended up delivering some drawing which had a sun in it. Maybe it was too big? IDK.
I don't want to whiteknight or whatever, but this is it. Gameforge did what they told us would do. You can be upset, but they don't have any reason to change their mind unless they want to appeal (something they don't really do) or if they find someone actually copied or requested from someone else.